“Templiers et Prieuré de Sion: La Filiation” is a rubbish book simply because it does not give the complete myth of the history of Pierre Plantard and the Priory of Sion 1988-2000.
The book was published by Les Éditions de L'Oeil du Sphinx by Philippe Marlin, who did not trust the primary source material given on this website – yet it has a good pedigree – namely Michel Vallet – who first discovered the said material in the Bibliothèque Nationale – who in turn passed on one scanned copy of the new version of “Vaincre” to Andreas Ardus, who uploaded it to the “Tamed Eyes” Yahoo Group, that was run by Frank McGovern. That was how I first found out about it.
A friction existed between Philippe Marlin and Jean-Luc Chaumeil – Philippe Marlin knew I was communicating with Jean-Luc Chaumeil – and therefore Philippe Marlin could have thought I was receiving all my information about the Priory of Sion 1998-2000 from Jean-Luc Chaumeil. But the simple fact is that Chaumeil himself did not know anything about this. The real person that made this discovery was Michel Vallet!
Putting it simply – Christian Tourrene could have made a mistake by trusting Philippe Marlin if he told him that the Priory of Sion material 1988-2000 was dodgy and could not be trusted. Either Pierre Plantard claimed that Roger-Patrice Pelat was a member of the Priory of Sion or he did not. Plantard obviously did make such a claim or he would never have gotten himself into trouble with Thierry Jean-Pierre. The reason why Pierre Plantard invented the Priory of Sion 1988-2000 with a totally different pedigree that did not involve the Knights Templar was because Plantard did not like the popularity of “L'Énigme Sacrée” by Michael Baigent, Richard Leigh and Henry Lincoln (Éditions Pygmalion/Gérard Watelet, 1983). Note that Henry Lincoln began writing books about Sacred Landscape Geometry while Michael Baigent and Richard Leigh went off on a completely different tangent altogether with their respective books.
It should be pointed out – hilariously – that Henry Lincoln was the recipient of the Prix Bérenger Saunière in 2012!
Philippe Marlin therefore belongs to the same company as “Isaac Ben Jacob” and in turn possibly has misled Christian Tourenne.